Голосование
* (2 чтение таб. 1 принятые поправки) О проекте федерального закона № 1179165-7 "О внесении изменений в Федеральный закон "О транспортной безопасности" (о проведении инструктажа и проверки знаний в области обеспечения транспортной безопасности)
2023-07-13 · созыв 8
Материалы инициативы
Законопроект № 1179165-7 · созыв 7
Пояснительная записка
Пояснительная записка к законопроекту (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и строительству)РП аЎ± б> юя b d юяяяaяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяямҐБ А р ї l{ bjbjR|R| B‚0 0 Ш4qяя яя яя ·T T Н Н Н Н Н яяяяб б б 8 $= б 3 ~ Y Y :“ “ “ n n n ¦ Ё Ё Ё Ё Ё Ё $± І c ‚М !Н n n n n n М Н Н “ “ Ын ‚ ‚ ‚ n ‚Н “ Н “ ¦ ‚ n ¦ ‚ ‚ ‚ “ яяяяР3ЏІ RЧ яяяяр "‚ ’ 03 ‚ е pе ‚ е Н ‚ n n ‚ n n n n n М М ‚ n n n 3 n n n n яяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяе n n n n n n n n n T ? “ : / ! " , / ! : ? @ > 5 : B C D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 " 2 = 5 A 5 = 8 8 8 7 = " B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 " 1. 1 I 8 5 E 0 @ 0 : B 5 @ 8 A B 8 : 8 ? @ > 5 : B 0 0 : B 0 8 4 - ? @ > 5 : B D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 . 0 8 2 0 = 8 5 2 = > A 8 3 > ? @ > 5 : B 0 0 : B 0 - ? @ > 5 : B D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 " 2 = 5 A 5 = 8 8 8 7 = " B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 ". $ 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = K 9 > @ 3 0 = 8 A ? > ; = 8 B 5 ; L = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 , 2 = > A O I 8 9 ? @ > 5 : B D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 - 8 = 8 A B 5 @ A B 2 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 . A = > 2 0 = 8 5 4 ; O ? > 4 3 > B > 2 : 8 ? @ > 5 : B 0 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 - 7 0 : > = > 4 0 B 5 ; L = 0 O 8 = 8 F 8 0 B 8 2 0 . 2. ? 8 A 0 = 8 5 ? @ > 1 ; 5 B > @ > 9 = 0 ? @ 0 2 ; 5 = ? @ > 5 : B 0 : B 0 , 1 > A = > 2 0 = 8 5 ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 6 8 4 0 5 B 8 E @ 5 0 ; 8 7 0 F 8 8 1) A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 8 8 A ? > ; > 6 5 = 8 O 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 > B 9 D 5 2 @ 0 ; O 2007 3 . ! 16-$ " B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 " (4 0 ; 5 5 - $ 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = K 9 7 0 : > = ! 16-$ ) ; 8 F 0 , > B 2 5 B A B 2 5 = = K 5 7 0 > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 2 A C 1 J 5 : B 5 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , = 0 > 1 J 5 : B 5 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > = 0 ; A C 1 J 5 : B 0 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , = 5 ? > A @ 5 4 A B 2 5 = = > A 2 O 7 0 = = K 9 A > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 > 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K 8 ; 8 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 O 2 ; O N B A O A 8 ; 0 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 O B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 , ? > 4 ; 5 6 0 I 8 1 O 7 0 B 5 ; L = > 9 ? > 4 3 > B > 2 : 5 8 0 B B 5 A B 0 F 8 8 . A 2 O 7 8 A M B 8 A C I 5 A B 2 ; 5 = 8 8 @ 5 0 ; 8 7 0 F 8 8 = > @ = > 4 0 B 5 ; L A B 2 0 2 > 1 ; 0 A B 8 > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 O B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 2 G 0 A B 8 ? > 4 3 > B > 2 : 8 8 0 B B 5 A B 0 F 8 8 ; 8 F , > B 2 5 B A B 2 5 = = K E 7 0 > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 = 0 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 , A C 1 J 5 : B K B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K (? 5 @ 5 2 > 7 G 8 : 8 ) = 5 A C B 7 = 0 G 8 B 5 ; L = C N D 8 = 0 = A > 2 C N = 0 3 @ C 7 : C . F 5 ; O E A = 8 6 5 = 8 O C : 0 7 0 = = > 9 D 8 = 0 = A > 2 > 9 = 0 3 @ C 7 : 8 , A C G 5 B > 1 O 7 0 B 5 ; L A B 2 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 2 A D 5 @ 5 7 0 I 8 B K > B 0 : B > 2 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 O 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 G 5 ; > 2 5 G 5 A : > 9 6 8 7 = 8 = 0 @ 5 ), 4 ; O ? 5 @ A > = 0 ; 0 (G ; 5 = > 2 M : 8 ? 0 6 5 9 ) > ? @ 5 4 5 ; 5 = = K E B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 @ 0 7 ; 8 G = K E 2 8 4 > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 ? @ > 5 : B > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 B A O 7 0 4 3 > B > 2 : C 8 0 B B 5 A B 0 F 8 N 2 > 1 ; 0 A B 8 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 = 0 ? @ > 2 5 4 5 = 8 5 8 = A B @ C : B 0 6 5 9 8 ? @ > 2 5 @ : C 7 = 0 = 8 9 , C 1 ; 0 A B 8 > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 O B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 . " 0 : , C G 8 B K 2 0 O , G B > ? 5 @ A > = 0 ; (M : 8 ? 0 6 ) B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 3 > A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 0 2 B > 1 8 ; L = > 3 > 8 3 > @ > 4 A : > 3 > = 0 7 5 3 > M ; 5 : B @ 8 G 5 A : > 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 , : 0 : ? @ 0 2 8 ; > , A > A B > 8 B 8 7 > 4 = > 3 > 2 > 4 8 B 5 ; O , 0 ; > : > B 8 2 = 0 O 1 @ 8 3 0 4 0 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 3 > A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 , > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O N I 5 3 > 6 5 ; 5 7 = > 4 > @ > 6 = K 5 ? 5 @ 5 2 > 7 : 8 2 ? @ 8 3 > @ > 4 = > > 1 I 5 = 8 8 , : 0 : ? @ 0 2 8 ; > , 2 : ; N G 0 5 B 2 A 2 > 9 A > A B 0 2 - I = 8 : 0 ? @ 8 1 J 5 4 3 > B > 2 : 8 A 8 ; > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 O B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 A ? > A ; 5 4 C N I 5 9 0 B B 5 A B 0 F 8 5 9 2 C A B 0 = > 2 ; 5 = = > @ O 4 : 5 , O 2 ; O 5 B A O 8 7 1 K B > G = K ? 0 A = > A B 8 2 ? @ > F 5 A A 5 ? 5 @ 5 2 > 7 : 8 , ? @ > 5 : B > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 B A O ? @ 8 > ? @ 5 4 5 ; 5 = 8 8 A C 1 J 5 : B > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K ? 5 @ A > = 0 ; 0 A C 1 J 5 : B 0 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , = 5 ? > A @ 5 4 A B 2 5 = = > A 2 O 7 0 = = > 3 > A > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 , 8 7 G 8 A ; 0 ? 5 @ A > = 0 ; 0 (M : 8 ? 0 6 0 ) B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 2 B > 1 8 ; L = > 3 > , 3 > @ > 4 A : > 3 > = 0 7 5 3 > M ; 5 : B @ 8 G 5 A : > 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 8 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 , > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O N I 8 E 6 5 ; 5 7 = > 4 > @ > 6 = K 5 ? 5 @ 5 2 > 7 : 8 2 ? @ 8 3 > @ > 4 = > > 1 I 5 = 8 8 , ? @ > 2 > 4 8 B L 2 > B = > H 5 = 8 8 B 0 : > 3 > ? 5 @ A > = 0 ; 0 (M : 8 ? 0 6 0 ) 8 = A B @ C : B 0 6 8 ? @ > 2 5 @ : C 7 = 0 = 8 9 2 > 1 ; 0 A B 8 > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 O B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 ; 8 F > B 2 5 B A B 2 5 = = K 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 2 A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 C N I 5 @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , 8 ; 8 ; 8 F > B 2 5 B A B 2 5 = = K 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 C N I 5 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 3 > A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 . = 0 ; > 3 8 G = 0 O A 8 B C 0 F 8 O A : ; 0 4 K 2 0 5 B A O 2 > B = > H 5 = 8 8 ? 5 @ A > = 0 ; 0 (M : 8 ? 0 6 0 ) B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 2 = C B @ 5 = = 5 3 > 2 > 4 = > 3 > 8 @ A : > 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 A G 8 A ; 5 = = > A B L N ? 5 @ A > = 0 ; 0 (M : 8 ? 0 6 0 ) = 5 1 > ; 5 5 B @ 5 E G 5 ; > 2 5 : , 0 B 0 : 6 5 A C 4 > 2 , 8 A ? > ; L 7 C 5 ; > 2 A B 2 0 , 2 > B = > H 5 = 8 8 : > B > @ K E = 5 ? @ 8 2 ; 5 = = K 5 4 = K 3 > 2 > @ 0 A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 B @ 5 1 > 2 0 = 8 O 2 > 1 ; 0 A B 8 > E @ 0 = K A C 4 > 2 8 ? > @ B > 2 K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 , ? > ; 0 3 0 5 2 ? @ 8 1 J 5 4 3 > B > 2 : 8 A 8 ; > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 O B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 A ? > A ; 5 4 C N I 5 9 0 B B 5 A B 0 F 8 5 9 2 C A B 0 = > 2 ; 5 = = > @ O 4 : 5 , B 0 : 6 5 O 2 ; O 5 B A O 8 7 1 K B > G = K 2 ; 0 4 5 = 8 O @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 2 ? @ > F 5 A A 5 ? 5 @ 5 2 > 7 : 8 , ? @ > 5 : B > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 B A O ? @ > 2 > 4 8 B L 2 > B = > H 5 = 8 8 ? 5 @ A > = 0 ; 0 (M : 8 ? 0 6 0 ) B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 8 = A B @ C : B 0 6 8 ? @ > 2 5 @ : C 7 = 0 = 8 9 2 > 1 ; 0 A B 8 > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 O B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 ; 8 F > B 2 5 B A B 2 5 = = K 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 C N I 5 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 3 > A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 , 8 7 G 8 A ; 0 : > 3 > A > A B 0 2 0 A C 4 = 0 . > ; C G 5 = = K 5 2 E > 4 5 8 = A B @ C : B 0 6 0 8 ? @ > 2 5 @ : 8 7 = 0 = 8 9 = 0 2 K : 8 = 5 > 1 E > 4 8 @ 2 0 = 8 O > 1 C 3 @ > 7 5 > A C I 5 A B 2 ; 5 = 8 O 0 : B 0 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 ; = 5 = 8 8 ? 5 @ 5 2 > 7 : 8 8 ? @ 8 = O B 8 O A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 C N I 8 E ? @ 5 2 5 = B 8 2 = K E 7 K A > 2 5 @ H 5 = 8 O 8 A > 2 5 @ H 5 = 8 O 0 : B 0 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 B = > H 5 = 8 8 : > = : @ 5 B = > 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 3 > A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 , C G 0 A B 8 O 2 ? @ > 2 5 @ : 5 8 = D > @ 1 C 3 @ > 7 5 A > 2 5 @ H 5 = 8 O 0 : B 0 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 B > @ K E : ? @ > 2 5 @ : 0 8 A ? @ 0 2 = > A B 8 B 5 E = 8 G 5 A : 8 E A @ 5 4 A B 2 > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 O B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 , 2 B > ? > 2 5 I 5 = 8 O ; ? @ > 2 5 4 5 = 8 5 > A B @ 0 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 3 > A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 ? @ 8 2 K E > 4 5 = 0 = 5 G = K 9 > A B 0 = > 2 > G = K 9 ? C = : B 2 F 5 ; O E 2 K O 2 ; 5 = 8 O ? > 4 > 7 @ 8 B 5 ; L = K E 8 ; 8 > A B 0 2 ; 5 = = K E 1 J 5 : B > 2 ; = 5 7 0 5 8 = D > @ 2 0 = 8 5 > 1 0 : B 0 E = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 1 = 0 @ C 6 5 = = K E ? > 4 > 7 @ 8 B 5 ; L = K E ? @ 5 4 2 8 > A B 0 2 ; 5 = = K E 2 5 I 5 9 ; 8 A : ; N G 5 = 8 5 (2 > A ? @ 5 ? O B A B 2 > 2 0 = 8 5 ) A 2 > 1 > 4 = > 3 > 4 > A B C ? 0 ? > A B > @ > = = 8 E ; 8 F = 0 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 5 A @ 5 4 A B 2 > 2 > 2 @ 5 A B > O = : 8 , > A C I 5 A B 2 ; 5 = 8 O ? > A 0 4 : 8 (2 K A 0 4 : 8 ), ? > 3 @ C 7 : 8 (2 K 3 @ C 7 : 8 ) 3 @ C 7 > 2 ; ? 5 @ 8 > 4 8 G 5 A : 8 9 = 8 B > @ 8 = 3 2 F 5 ; O E 2 K O 2 ; 5 = 8 O A 8 A ? > ; L 7 > 2 0 = 8 5 B > @ K E C A 4 3 > B > 2 : 8 : A > 2 5 @ H 5 = 8 N 0 : B 0 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 2 K E = 0 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 2 0 = 8 O > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 N B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 > 1 5 A ? 5 G 8 B L M 2 0 : C 0 F 8 N ? 0 A A 0 6 8 @ > 2 , 2 B > 3 > 0 : B 0 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 O I 5 5 2 @ 5 1 J 5 : B K B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K 8 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K 5 A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 , > ? @ 5 4 5 ; 5 = = K 5 2 7 = 0 G 5 = 8 O E $ 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 ! 16-$ ? > 4 ; 5 6 0 B 7 0 I 8 B 5 > B 0 : B > 2 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 = = > 3 > 2 3 ; 0 A = > ? C = : B C 1 A B 0 B L 8 1 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 ! 16-$ , M B > ? @ > B 8 2 > ? @ 0 2 = > 5 4 5 9 A B 2 8 5 (1 5 7 4 5 9 A B 2 8 5 ), 2 B > @ 8 A B 8 G 5 A : 8 9 0 : B , C 3 @ > 6 0 N I 5 5 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > 9 4 5 O B 5 ; L = > A B 8 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 3 > : > 2 ; 5 : H 5 5 7 0 A > 1 > 9 ? @ 8 G 8 = 5 = 8 5 2 @ 5 4 0 6 8 7 = 8 8 7 4 > @ > 2 L N ; N 4 5 9 , A > 7 4 0 2 H 5 5 C 3 @ > 7 C = 0 A B C ? ; 5 = 8 O B 0 : 8 E ? > A ; 5 4 A B 2 8 9 . A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 8 8 A 7 0 : > = > 4 0 B 5 ; L A B 2 > 1 ; 0 A B 8 > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 O B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 7 0 I 8 B 0 > 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K l n љ В Д ъ ь P X Z Ь Ю
j
l
ў
¤
B D F H J P 8 : \ Ю а ш H L Z \ „ † ^ ` ¤ Ё . 0 В Д " $ ґ ¶ ю – М О , 0 Ж И Њ Ћ Є ¬ ш ъ ътнтитнтнтдаЩтЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩФтЩтЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдРЙЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩд h|J? hµ|B h р hµ|B5 Ѓ h|J? h|J? hЇ1& h|J? hфQS5 Ѓ h|J?5 Ѓ h|J? h|J?5 Ѓ h р5 ЃO . 0 P ” Ё
ў H J \ " " $ 2 T P$А(4,чмбмчччШШШШШМШШШШШШШШШШ „Е dа `„Е gdµ|B „Е `„Е gd|J?
$ d€яa$ gd|J?
$ dрa$ gd|J? $ a$ gdµ|B ъ Є#¬#R%T%r't'м+о+:. = = > 3 > 2 A C I 5 A B 2 ; O 5 B A O ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 . @ 8 M B > B 4 5 ; L = K 5 > 1 J 5 : B K B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K ? > B 0 : B > 2 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 4 ; 5 6 0 B > E @ 0 = 5 ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 9 > E @ 0 = K D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = K E > @ 3 0 = > 2 8 A ? > ; = 8 B 5 ; L = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 2 > 1 ; 0 A B 8 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 . > ; > 6 5 = 8 O = > B 10 O = 2 0 @ O 2003 3 . ! 17-$ " 6 5 ; 5 7 = > 4 > @ > 6 = > @ B 5 2 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 " > ? @ 5 4 5 ; 5 = > , G B > > E @ 0 = 0 = 0 8 1 > ; 5 5 2 0 6 = K E > 1 J 5 : B > 2 6 5 ; 5 7 = > 4 > @ > 6 = > 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 > 1 I 5 3 > ? > ; L 7 > 2 0 = 8 O 8 A ? 5 F 8 0 ; L = K E 3 @ C 7 > 2 > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O 5 B A O ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 9 > E @ 0 = K D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > > @ 3 0 = 0 8 A ? > ; = 8 B 5 ; L = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 2 > 1 ; 0 A B 8 6 5 ; 5 7 = > 4 > @ > 6 = > 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 , 2 > 9 A : = 0 F 8 > = 0 ; L = > 9 3 2 0 @ 4 8 8 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 8 8 = K ; = > G 5 = = K 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 1 J 5 : B > 2 8 3 @ C 7 > 2 C A B 0 = 0 2 ; 8 2 0 N B A O @ 0 2 8 B 5 ; L A B 2 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 . @ 8 : 0 7 > A A 8 8 > B 3 0 2 3 C A B 0 2016 3 . ! 222 C B 2 5 @ 6 4 5 = 5 @ 5 G 5 = L > E @ 0 = O 5 1 J 5 : B > 2 ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 3 > 3 > A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = > 3 > C = 8 B 0 @ = > 3 > ? @ 5 4 ? @ 8 O B 8 O "# ? @ 0 2 ; 5 = 8 5 2 5 4 > 9 > E @ 0 = K 8 = 8 A B 5 @ A B 2 0 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 ". A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 8 8 A ? C = : B > E @ 0 = K 0 M @ > ? > @ B > 2 8 > 1 J 5 : B > 2 8 E 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , C B 2 5 @ 6 4 5 = = K E ? > A B 0 = > 2 ; 5 = 8 5 A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 > B 1 D 5 2 @ 0 ; O 2011 3 . ! 42 > E @ 0 = 0 3 @ 0 = 8 F B 5 @ @ 8 B > @ 8 8 0 M @ > ? > @ B 0 , = 5 2 : ; N G 5 = = > 3 > 2 ? 5 @ 5 G 5 = L > 1 J 5 : B > 2 , ? > 4 ; 5 6 0 I 8 E > 1 O 7 0 B 5 ; L = > 9 > E @ 0 = 5 2 > 9 A : 0 = 0 ; L = > 9 3 2 0 @ 4 8 8 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 , > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O 5 B A O ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 9 > E @ 0 = K 8 = 8 A B 5 @ A B 2 0 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 . ! > 3 ; 0 A = > ? > ; > 6 5 = 8 O 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 > B 14 0 ? @ 5 ; O 1999 3 . ! 77-$ " 2 5 4 > 9 > E @ 0 = 5 " > A = > 2 = K E @ 0 = K 2 B > E @ 0 = O 5 1 J 5 : B > 2 > B ? @ > B 8 2 > ? @ 0 2 = K E ? > A O 3 0 B 5 ; L A B 2 8 > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 = 0 > E @ 0 = O 5 1 J 5 : B 0 E ? @ > ? C A : = > 3 > 8 2 = C B @ 8 > 1 J 5 : B > 2 > 3 > @ 5 6 8 2 . M B > 9 A 2 O 7 8 C A C 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K 2 > 7 = 8 : 0 N B 4 2 > 9 = K 5 D 8 = 0 = A > 2 K 5 7 0 B @ 0 B K - = 0 ? @ 8 2 ; 5 G 5 = 8 5 ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 9 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 4 ; O 7 0 I 8 B K > B 0 : B > 2 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 9 2 5 4 > 9 > E @ 0 = K 4 ; O 7 0 I 8 B K > B ? @ > B 8 2 > ? @ 0 2 = K E ? > A O 3 0 B 5 ; L A B 2 2 @ 0 E @ 0 = K > 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K 8 (8 ; 8 ) B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 . F 5 ; O E > ? B 8 2 K E 7 0 B @ 0 B A C 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , ? > 4 ? C = : B > 5 : B 0 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 B A O C A B 0 = > 2 8 B L , G B > 7 0 I 8 B 0 > B 0 : B > 2 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , ? > 4 ; 5 6 0 I 8 E > E @ 0 = 5 ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 9 > E @ 0 = K D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = K E > @ 3 0 = > 2 8 A ? > ; = 8 B 5 ; L = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 2 > 1 ; 0 A B 8 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 , 2 : ; N G 0 5 B 2 A 5 1 O 8 E 7 0 I 8 B C > B ? @ > B 8 2 > ? @ 0 2 = K E ? > A O 3 0 B 5 ; L A B 2 8 > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O 5 B A O C : 0 7 0 = = K 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 . 5 0 ; 8 7 0 F 8 O ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 @ 7 2 > ; 8 B 8 A : ; N G 8 B L = 5 > 1 E > 4 8 A B L > 4 = > 2 @ 5 9 7 0 I 8 B K > B 0 : B > 2 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 E @ 0 = K > B 4 5 ; L = K E > 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , G B > ? > 7 2 > ; 8 B 8 A : ; N G 8 B L 4 2 > 9 = K 5 7 0 B @ 0 B K A C 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , D 8 = 0 = A 8 @ > 2 0 = 8 5 : > B > @ K E , 2 B > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O 5 B A O 8 7 1 N 4 6 5 B = > 9 A 8 A B 5 A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 . 3) F 5 ; O E 8 A : ; N G 5 = 8 O = 5 > 4 = > 7 = 0 G = > 3 > B @ 0 : B > 2 0 = 8 O ? > ; > 6 5 = 8 9 ? C = : B 0 1.4 A B 0 B L 8 1 8 G 0 A B 8 7 A B 0 B L 8 12.1 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 ! 16-$ , ? > 4 ? C = : B > 5 : B 0 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 B A O 8 A : ; N G 8 B L > 3 @ 0 = 8 G 5 = 8 5 , A 2 O 7 0 = = > 5 A ? > : 0 7 0 = 8 O ; = 5 = 8 N @ 0 1 > B , = 5 ? > A @ 5 4 A B 2 5 = = > A 2 O 7 0 = = K E A > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 , 2 A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 8 8 A A B 8 ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 5 : B 0 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 = 5 ? @ 5 4 ? > ; 0 3 0 N B C 2 5 ; 8 G 5 = 8 O G 8 A ; 5 = = > A B 8 @ 0 1 > B = 8 : > 2 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = K E > @ 3 0 = > 2 8 A ? > ; = 8 B 5 ; L = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 , = 5 ? > B @ 5 1 C 5 B 4 > ? > ; = 8 B 5 ; L = K E @ 0 A E > 4 > 2 8 7 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 1 N 4 6 5 B 0 8 8 7 @ O 4 : 0 D 8 = 0 = A 8 @ > 2 0 = 8 O D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = K E > @ 3 0 = > 2 8 A ? > ; = 8 B 5 ; L = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 . @ 8 = O B 8 5 ? @ > 5 : B 0 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 ? > 7 2 > ; 8 B > ? B 8 2 0 B L D 8 = 0 = A > 2 K 5 8 > @ 3 0 = 8 7 0 F 8 > = = K 5 7 0 B @ 0 B K A C 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , ? 5 @ 5 2 > 7 G 8 : > 2 1 5 7 A = 8 6 5 = 8 O C @ > 2 = O 7 0 I 8 I 5 = = > A B 8 > 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K 8 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 ? > 2 8 4 0 @ B 0 > B 0 : B > 2 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 @ 3 0 = > 2 3 > A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 A C 1 J 5 : B > 2 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 8 (8 ; 8 ) > @ 3 0 = > 2 3 > A 0 C ? @ 0 2 ; 5 = 8 O @ 8 = O B 8 5 8 @ 5 0 ; 8 7 0 F 8 O ? @ > 5 : B 0 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 = 5 > : 0 6 5 B 2 ; 8 O = 8 O = 0 4 5 O B 5 ; L = > A B L > @ 3 0 = > 2 3 > A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 A C 1 J 5 : B > 2 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 8 (8 ; 8 ) > @ 3 0 = > 2 3 > A 0 C ? @ 0 2 ; 5 = 8 O , 0 B 0 : 6 5 = 5 2 ; 8 O 5 B = 0 4 > A B 8 6 5 = 8 5 F 5 ; 5 9 3 > A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = K E ? @ > 3 @ 0 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 . 5. ! > > B 2 5 B A B 2 8 5 ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 ; > 6 5 = 8 O 3 > 2 > @ 0 > 2 @ 0 7 8 9 A : > = > N 7 5 , 0 B 0 : 6 5 ? > ; > 6 5 = 8 O 3 > 2 > @ > 2 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 @ > 5 : B D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 = 5 ? @ > B 8 2 > @ 5 G 8 B ? > ; > 6 5 = 8 O 3 > 2 > @ 0 > 2 @ 0 7 8 9 A : > = > N 7 5 , 0 B 0 : 6 5 ? > ; > 6 5 = 8 O 3 > 2 > @ > 2 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 . 6. = D > @ = 0 ; 8 G 8 8 8 ; 8 > B A C B A B 2 8 8 2 ? @ > 5 : B 5 0 : B 0 > 1 O 7 0 B 5 ; L = K E B @ 5 1 > 2 0 = 8 9 , > F 5 = : 0 A > 1 ; N 4 5 = 8 O : > B > @ K E > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O 5 B A O 2 @ 0 A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = > 3 > : > = B @ > ; O (= 0 4 7 > @ 0 ), 3 > : > = B @ > ; O , ? @ 8 @ 0 A A B @ 5 = 8 8 4 5 ; > 1 0 4 = 0 @ C H 5 = 8 O E , 8 ; 8 > 1 O 7 0 B 5 ; L = K E B @ 5 1 > 2 0 = 8 9 , A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 8 5 : > B > @ K 2 5 @ O 5 B A O ? @ 8 2 K 4 0 G 5 @ 0 7 @ 5 H 5 = 8 9 , ; 8 F 5 = 7 8 9 , 0 B B 5 A B 0 B > 2 0 : : @ 5 4 8 B 0 F 8 8 , 8 = K E 4 > : C 2 , 8 A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 C N I 5 A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = > 3 > : > = B @ > ; O (= 0 4 7 > @ 0 ), 2 8 4 5 @ 0 7 @ 5 H 8 B 5 ; L = > 9 4 5 O B 5 ; L = > A B 8 8 ? @ 5 4 ? > ; 0 3 0 5 9 > B 2 5 B A B 2 5 = = > A B 8 7 0 = 0 @ C H 5 = 8 5 > 1 O 7 0 B 5 ; L = K E B @ 5 1 > 2 0 = 8 9 8 ; 8 ? > A ; 5 4 A B 2 8 O E 8 E = 5 A > 1 ; N 4 5 = 8 O > 4 ? C = : B > 5 : B 0 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 C A B 0 = 0 2 ; 8 2 0 5 B A O > 1 O 7 0 B 5 ; L = > 5 B @ 5 1 > 2 0 = 8 5 : > ? @ > 2 5 4 5 = 8 8 ; 8 F > B 2 5 B A B 2 5 = = K 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 2 A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 C N I 5 @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , 8 ; 8 ; 8 F > B 2 5 B A B 2 5 = = K 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 C N I 5 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 3 > A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 , 8 = A B @ C : B 0 6 0 8 ? @ > 2 5 @ : 8 7 = 0 = 8 9 2 > B = > H 5 = 8 8 ? 5 @ A > = 0 ; 0 (M : 8 ? 0 6 0 ) B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 2 B > 1 8 ; L = > 3 > , 3 > @ > 4 A : > 3 > = 0 7 5 3 > M ; 5 : B @ 8 G 5 A : > 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 8 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 , > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O N I 8 E 6 5 ; 5 7 = > 4 > @ > 6 = K 5 ? 5 @ 5 2 > 7 : 8 2 ? @ 8 3 > @ > 4 = > > 1 I 5 = 8 8 ; > ? @ > 2 5 4 5 = 8 8 ; 8 F > B 2 5 B A B 2 5 = = K 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 C N I 5 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 3 > A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 , 8 7 G 8 A ; 0 : > 3 > A > A B 0 2 0 A C 4 = 0 , 8 = A B @ C : B 0 6 0 8 ? @ > 2 5 @ : 8 7 = 0 = 8 9 2 > B = > H 5 = 8 8 ? 5 @ A > = 0 ; 0 (M : 8 ? 0 6 0 ) B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 2 = C B @ 5 = = 5 3 > 2 > 4 = > 3 > 8 @ A : > 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 A G 8 A…
j
l
ў
¤
B D F H J P 8 : \ Ю а ш H L Z \ „ † ^ ` ¤ Ё . 0 В Д " $ ґ ¶ ю – М О , 0 Ж И Њ Ћ Є ¬ ш ъ ътнтитнтнтдаЩтЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩФтЩтЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдРЙЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩдЩд h|J? hµ|B h р hµ|B5 Ѓ h|J? h|J? hЇ1& h|J? hфQS5 Ѓ h|J?5 Ѓ h|J? h|J?5 Ѓ h р5 ЃO . 0 P ” Ё
ў H J \ " " $ 2 T P$А(4,чмбмчччШШШШШМШШШШШШШШШШ „Е dа `„Е gdµ|B „Е `„Е gd|J?
$ d€яa$ gd|J?
$ dрa$ gd|J? $ a$ gdµ|B ъ Є#¬#R%T%r't'м+о+:. = = > 3 > 2 A C I 5 A B 2 ; O 5 B A O ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 . @ 8 M B > B 4 5 ; L = K 5 > 1 J 5 : B K B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K ? > B 0 : B > 2 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 4 ; 5 6 0 B > E @ 0 = 5 ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 9 > E @ 0 = K D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = K E > @ 3 0 = > 2 8 A ? > ; = 8 B 5 ; L = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 2 > 1 ; 0 A B 8 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 . > ; > 6 5 = 8 O = > B 10 O = 2 0 @ O 2003 3 . ! 17-$ " 6 5 ; 5 7 = > 4 > @ > 6 = > @ B 5 2 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 " > ? @ 5 4 5 ; 5 = > , G B > > E @ 0 = 0 = 0 8 1 > ; 5 5 2 0 6 = K E > 1 J 5 : B > 2 6 5 ; 5 7 = > 4 > @ > 6 = > 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 > 1 I 5 3 > ? > ; L 7 > 2 0 = 8 O 8 A ? 5 F 8 0 ; L = K E 3 @ C 7 > 2 > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O 5 B A O ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 9 > E @ 0 = K D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > > @ 3 0 = 0 8 A ? > ; = 8 B 5 ; L = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 2 > 1 ; 0 A B 8 6 5 ; 5 7 = > 4 > @ > 6 = > 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 , 2 > 9 A : = 0 F 8 > = 0 ; L = > 9 3 2 0 @ 4 8 8 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 8 8 = K ; = > G 5 = = K 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 1 J 5 : B > 2 8 3 @ C 7 > 2 C A B 0 = 0 2 ; 8 2 0 N B A O @ 0 2 8 B 5 ; L A B 2 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 . @ 8 : 0 7 > A A 8 8 > B 3 0 2 3 C A B 0 2016 3 . ! 222 C B 2 5 @ 6 4 5 = 5 @ 5 G 5 = L > E @ 0 = O 5 1 J 5 : B > 2 ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 3 > 3 > A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = > 3 > C = 8 B 0 @ = > 3 > ? @ 5 4 ? @ 8 O B 8 O "# ? @ 0 2 ; 5 = 8 5 2 5 4 > 9 > E @ 0 = K 8 = 8 A B 5 @ A B 2 0 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 ". A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 8 8 A ? C = : B > E @ 0 = K 0 M @ > ? > @ B > 2 8 > 1 J 5 : B > 2 8 E 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , C B 2 5 @ 6 4 5 = = K E ? > A B 0 = > 2 ; 5 = 8 5 A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 > B 1 D 5 2 @ 0 ; O 2011 3 . ! 42 > E @ 0 = 0 3 @ 0 = 8 F B 5 @ @ 8 B > @ 8 8 0 M @ > ? > @ B 0 , = 5 2 : ; N G 5 = = > 3 > 2 ? 5 @ 5 G 5 = L > 1 J 5 : B > 2 , ? > 4 ; 5 6 0 I 8 E > 1 O 7 0 B 5 ; L = > 9 > E @ 0 = 5 2 > 9 A : 0 = 0 ; L = > 9 3 2 0 @ 4 8 8 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 , > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O 5 B A O ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 9 > E @ 0 = K 8 = 8 A B 5 @ A B 2 0 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 . ! > 3 ; 0 A = > ? > ; > 6 5 = 8 O 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 > B 14 0 ? @ 5 ; O 1999 3 . ! 77-$ " 2 5 4 > 9 > E @ 0 = 5 " > A = > 2 = K E @ 0 = K 2 B > E @ 0 = O 5 1 J 5 : B > 2 > B ? @ > B 8 2 > ? @ 0 2 = K E ? > A O 3 0 B 5 ; L A B 2 8 > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 = 0 > E @ 0 = O 5 1 J 5 : B 0 E ? @ > ? C A : = > 3 > 8 2 = C B @ 8 > 1 J 5 : B > 2 > 3 > @ 5 6 8 2 . M B > 9 A 2 O 7 8 C A C 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K 2 > 7 = 8 : 0 N B 4 2 > 9 = K 5 D 8 = 0 = A > 2 K 5 7 0 B @ 0 B K - = 0 ? @ 8 2 ; 5 G 5 = 8 5 ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 9 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 4 ; O 7 0 I 8 B K > B 0 : B > 2 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 9 2 5 4 > 9 > E @ 0 = K 4 ; O 7 0 I 8 B K > B ? @ > B 8 2 > ? @ 0 2 = K E ? > A O 3 0 B 5 ; L A B 2 2 @ 0 E @ 0 = K > 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K 8 (8 ; 8 ) B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 . F 5 ; O E > ? B 8 2 K E 7 0 B @ 0 B A C 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , ? > 4 ? C = : B > 5 : B 0 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 B A O C A B 0 = > 2 8 B L , G B > 7 0 I 8 B 0 > B 0 : B > 2 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , ? > 4 ; 5 6 0 I 8 E > E @ 0 = 5 ? > 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 9 > E @ 0 = K D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = K E > @ 3 0 = > 2 8 A ? > ; = 8 B 5 ; L = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 2 > 1 ; 0 A B 8 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 , 2 : ; N G 0 5 B 2 A 5 1 O 8 E 7 0 I 8 B C > B ? @ > B 8 2 > ? @ 0 2 = K E ? > A O 3 0 B 5 ; L A B 2 8 > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O 5 B A O C : 0 7 0 = = K 4 @ 0 7 4 5 ; 5 = 8 O 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 . 5 0 ; 8 7 0 F 8 O ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 @ 7 2 > ; 8 B 8 A : ; N G 8 B L = 5 > 1 E > 4 8 A B L > 4 = > 2 @ 5 9 7 0 I 8 B K > B 0 : B > 2 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 E @ 0 = K > B 4 5 ; L = K E > 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , G B > ? > 7 2 > ; 8 B 8 A : ; N G 8 B L 4 2 > 9 = K 5 7 0 B @ 0 B K A C 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , D 8 = 0 = A 8 @ > 2 0 = 8 5 : > B > @ K E , 2 B > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O 5 B A O 8 7 1 N 4 6 5 B = > 9 A 8 A B 5 A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 . 3) F 5 ; O E 8 A : ; N G 5 = 8 O = 5 > 4 = > 7 = 0 G = > 3 > B @ 0 : B > 2 0 = 8 O ? > ; > 6 5 = 8 9 ? C = : B 0 1.4 A B 0 B L 8 1 8 G 0 A B 8 7 A B 0 B L 8 12.1 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 ! 16-$ , ? > 4 ? C = : B > 5 : B 0 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 B A O 8 A : ; N G 8 B L > 3 @ 0 = 8 G 5 = 8 5 , A 2 O 7 0 = = > 5 A ? > : 0 7 0 = 8 O ; = 5 = 8 N @ 0 1 > B , = 5 ? > A @ 5 4 A B 2 5 = = > A 2 O 7 0 = = K E A > 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 , 2 A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 8 8 A A B 8 ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 5 : B 0 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 = 5 ? @ 5 4 ? > ; 0 3 0 N B C 2 5 ; 8 G 5 = 8 O G 8 A ; 5 = = > A B 8 @ 0 1 > B = 8 : > 2 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = K E > @ 3 0 = > 2 8 A ? > ; = 8 B 5 ; L = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 , = 5 ? > B @ 5 1 C 5 B 4 > ? > ; = 8 B 5 ; L = K E @ 0 A E > 4 > 2 8 7 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 1 N 4 6 5 B 0 8 8 7 @ O 4 : 0 D 8 = 0 = A 8 @ > 2 0 = 8 O D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = K E > @ 3 0 = > 2 8 A ? > ; = 8 B 5 ; L = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 . @ 8 = O B 8 5 ? @ > 5 : B 0 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 ? > 7 2 > ; 8 B > ? B 8 2 0 B L D 8 = 0 = A > 2 K 5 8 > @ 3 0 = 8 7 0 F 8 > = = K 5 7 0 B @ 0 B K A C 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , ? 5 @ 5 2 > 7 G 8 : > 2 1 5 7 A = 8 6 5 = 8 O C @ > 2 = O 7 0 I 8 I 5 = = > A B 8 > 1 J 5 : B > 2 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K 8 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 ? > 2 8 4 0 @ B 0 > B 0 : B > 2 = 5 7 0 : > = = > 3 > 2 @ 3 0 = > 2 3 > A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 A C 1 J 5 : B > 2 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 8 (8 ; 8 ) > @ 3 0 = > 2 3 > A 0 C ? @ 0 2 ; 5 = 8 O @ 8 = O B 8 5 8 @ 5 0 ; 8 7 0 F 8 O ? @ > 5 : B 0 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 = 5 > : 0 6 5 B 2 ; 8 O = 8 O = 0 4 5 O B 5 ; L = > A B L > @ 3 0 = > 2 3 > A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = > 9 2 ; 0 A B 8 A C 1 J 5 : B > 2 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 8 (8 ; 8 ) > @ 3 0 = > 2 3 > A 0 C ? @ 0 2 ; 5 = 8 O , 0 B 0 : 6 5 = 5 2 ; 8 O 5 B = 0 4 > A B 8 6 5 = 8 5 F 5 ; 5 9 3 > A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = K E ? @ > 3 @ 0 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 . 5. ! > > B 2 5 B A B 2 8 5 ? @ 5 4 ; 0 3 0 5 ; > 6 5 = 8 O 3 > 2 > @ 0 > 2 @ 0 7 8 9 A : > = > N 7 5 , 0 B 0 : 6 5 ? > ; > 6 5 = 8 O 3 > 2 > @ > 2 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 @ > 5 : B D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 = 5 ? @ > B 8 2 > @ 5 G 8 B ? > ; > 6 5 = 8 O 3 > 2 > @ 0 > 2 @ 0 7 8 9 A : > = > N 7 5 , 0 B 0 : 6 5 ? > ; > 6 5 = 8 O 3 > 2 > @ > 2 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 . 6. = D > @ = 0 ; 8 G 8 8 8 ; 8 > B A C B A B 2 8 8 2 ? @ > 5 : B 5 0 : B 0 > 1 O 7 0 B 5 ; L = K E B @ 5 1 > 2 0 = 8 9 , > F 5 = : 0 A > 1 ; N 4 5 = 8 O : > B > @ K E > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O 5 B A O 2 @ 0 A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = > 3 > : > = B @ > ; O (= 0 4 7 > @ 0 ), 3 > : > = B @ > ; O , ? @ 8 @ 0 A A B @ 5 = 8 8 4 5 ; > 1 0 4 = 0 @ C H 5 = 8 O E , 8 ; 8 > 1 O 7 0 B 5 ; L = K E B @ 5 1 > 2 0 = 8 9 , A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 8 5 : > B > @ K 2 5 @ O 5 B A O ? @ 8 2 K 4 0 G 5 @ 0 7 @ 5 H 5 = 8 9 , ; 8 F 5 = 7 8 9 , 0 B B 5 A B 0 B > 2 0 : : @ 5 4 8 B 0 F 8 8 , 8 = K E 4 > : C 2 , 8 A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 C N I 5 A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = > 3 > : > = B @ > ; O (= 0 4 7 > @ 0 ), 2 8 4 5 @ 0 7 @ 5 H 8 B 5 ; L = > 9 4 5 O B 5 ; L = > A B 8 8 ? @ 5 4 ? > ; 0 3 0 5 9 > B 2 5 B A B 2 5 = = > A B 8 7 0 = 0 @ C H 5 = 8 5 > 1 O 7 0 B 5 ; L = K E B @ 5 1 > 2 0 = 8 9 8 ; 8 ? > A ; 5 4 A B 2 8 O E 8 E = 5 A > 1 ; N 4 5 = 8 O > 4 ? C = : B > 5 : B 0 D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 C A B 0 = 0 2 ; 8 2 0 5 B A O > 1 O 7 0 B 5 ; L = > 5 B @ 5 1 > 2 0 = 8 5 : > ? @ > 2 5 4 5 = 8 8 ; 8 F > B 2 5 B A B 2 5 = = K 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 2 A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 C N I 5 @ B = > 9 8 = D @ 0 A B @ C : B C @ K , 8 ; 8 ; 8 F > B 2 5 B A B 2 5 = = K 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 C N I 5 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 3 > A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 , 8 = A B @ C : B 0 6 0 8 ? @ > 2 5 @ : 8 7 = 0 = 8 9 2 > B = > H 5 = 8 8 ? 5 @ A > = 0 ; 0 (M : 8 ? 0 6 0 ) B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 2 B > 1 8 ; L = > 3 > , 3 > @ > 4 A : > 3 > = 0 7 5 3 > M ; 5 : B @ 8 G 5 A : > 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 8 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 , > A C I 5 A B 2 ; O N I 8 E 6 5 ; 5 7 = > 4 > @ > 6 = K 5 ? 5 @ 5 2 > 7 : 8 2 ? @ 8 3 > @ > 4 = > > 1 I 5 = 8 8 ; > ? @ > 2 5 4 5 = 8 8 ; 8 F > B 2 5 B A B 2 5 = = K 1 5 A ? 5 G 5 = 8 5 B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 9 1 5 7 > ? 0 A = > A B 8 A > > B 2 5 B A B 2 C N I 5 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = > 3 > A @ 5 4 A B 2 0 , 8 7 G 8 A ; 0 : > 3 > A > A B 0 2 0 A C 4 = 0 , 8 = A B @ C : B 0 6 0 8 ? @ > 2 5 @ : 8 7 = 0 = 8 9 2 > B = > H 5 = 8 8 ? 5 @ A > = 0 ; 0 (M : 8 ? 0 6 0 ) B @ 0 = A ? > @ B = K E A @ 5 4 A B 2 2 = C B @ 5 = = 5 3 > 2 > 4 = > 3 > 8 @ A : > 3 > B @ 0 = A ? > @ B 0 A G 8 A…
Прикрепленные файлы
Пакет документов при внесении
Текст внесенного законопроекта (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и строительству)
Пояснительная записка к законопроекту (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и строительству)
Финансово-экономическое обоснование (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и строительству)
Перечень федеральных законов, подлежащих признанию утратившими силу, приостановлению, изменению или принятию (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и строительству)
Перечень нормативных правовых актов Президента Российской Федерации, Правительства Российской Федерации и федеральных органов исполнительной власти, подлежащих признанию утратившими силу, приостановлению, изменению или принятию (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и строительству)
Проект решения Совета Государственной Думы (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и строительству)
Письмо в Совет Государственной Думы (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и строительству)
Решение профильного комитета (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и строительству)
315, п.133
3, п.19
Решение ответственного комитета (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
Заключение ответственного комитета (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
Письмо в Совет Государственной Думы (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
Проект постановления Государственной Думы (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
Проект решения Совета Государственной Думы (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
Заключение Правового управления(повторно)
Заключение Правового управления
36, п.36
Таблица поправок, рекомендуемых к принятию (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
Заключение Правового управления
Решение комитета (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
Проект постановления Государственной Думы (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
Письмо в Совет ГД (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
Проект решения Совета Государственной Думы (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
Текст законопроекта ко второму чтению с учетом поправок, рекомендуемых ответственным комитетом к принятию (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
115, п.23
Текст законопроекта к третьему чтению (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
Проект Постановления Государственной Думы (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
Заключение Правового управления
Иной документ (Комитет Государственной Думы по транспорту и развитию транспортной инфраструктуры)
Заключение Правового управления Аппарата Совета Федерации
Заключение Комитета Совета Федерации по экономической политике
Заключение Комитета Совета Федерации по обороне и безопасности
Постановление Совета Федерации
650d3f28-7b72-4ec0-a80d-767f2ad49119
7ee176d4-058b-41e5-8388-509ef8c7e24c
d051ee81-2743-4211-a650-dc36d1528d5d
f5dd99fe-93d5-4c32-bdc9-5371edd21f9e
9018e467-b11f-4f4a-8976-015dffdef748
32b7c199-84e3-4692-9be3-07d96a23fb14
aff1fb88-74ad-46a6-9d9d-e6e29199361c
517f449a-1859-4b5d-b00b-65b83b800d54
Реакция фракций
Внутреннее кольцо показывает фракции, внешнее — распределение голосов внутри каждой фракции.
ЕДИНАЯ РОССИЯ
За · 88.8%
За 285 · Против 0 · Воздержались 0 · Не участвовали 36
КПРФ
Не участвовала · 100%
За 0 · Против 0 · Воздержались 0 · Не участвовали 57
СПРАВЕДЛИВАЯ РОССИЯ
Воздержалась · 70.4%
За 3 · Против 0 · Воздержались 19 · Не участвовали 5
ЛДПР
За · 61.9%
За 13 · Против 0 · Воздержались 0 · Не участвовали 8
НОВЫЕ ЛЮДИ
За · 80%
За 12 · Против 0 · Воздержались 0 · Не участвовали 3
Не входящие во фракции
Не участвовала · 50%
За 1 · Против 0 · Воздержались 1 · Не участвовали 2
Поименные данные
Показано: 445