Голосование
(2 чтение таб. 1 принятые поправки) О проекте федерального закона № 51743-4 " О внесении изменений в статью 223 части первой Гражданского кодекса Российской Федерации и Федеральный закон "О государственной регистрации прав на недвижимое имущество и сделок с ним"
2004-07-10 · созыв 4
Материалы инициативы
Законопроект № 51743-4 · созыв 4
Пояснительная записка
Пояснительная запискаРП аЎ± б> юя V X юяяяUяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяямҐБM р ї bn bjbjв=в= .xЂWЂW15яя яя яя lЁЁЁЁЁЁЁ „ Љ Љ Љ Љ – „ џ ¶¶ ¶ ¶ ¶ ¶ ¶ ¶ ¶ $U u
fD Ё¶ ¶ ¶ ¶ ¶ D l ЁЁ¶ ¶ Y l l l ¶ B Ё¶ Ё¶ l ¶ l Іl ЁЁ ¶ Є АЕ»+ 8Д „ Љ ш j o 0џ Ы
b
Ы
l јt0 TЁЁЁЁ Щ / ! " , / ! : ? @ > 5 : B C D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 « 2 = 5 A 5 = 8 8 8 7 3 > : > 4 5 : A 0 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 8 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = K 9 7 0 : > = « 3 > A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = > 9 @ 5 3 8 A B @ 0 F 8 8 ? @ 0 2 = 0 = 5 4 2 8 6 8 5 8 8 A 4 5 ; > : A = 8 = > ? @ > 5 : B 0 O 2 ; O 5 B A O A > 2 5 @ H 5 = A B 2 > 2 0 = 8 5 A 8 A B 5 1 A B 2 5 = = > A B 8 = 0 = 5 4 2 8 6 8 5 8 »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О Р €
| ~ Ђ ”OtPvPxP|P2R4RР_Т_мkоkрk`nbnщхрщищрщЮищрШрШрПШр CJ aJ mH sH CJ H* aJ 5 ЃCJ aJ mH sH 5 ЃCJ H* aJ CJ aJ 5 ЃaJ 5 ЃCJ aJ . t О Р Т ¤ €
Љ
Ђ V Ц D Ц $т&0*"1.8^
fD Ё¶ ¶ ¶ ¶ ¶ D l ЁЁ¶ ¶ Y l l l ¶ B Ё¶ Ё¶ l ¶ l Іl ЁЁ ¶ Є АЕ»+ 8Д „ Љ ш j o 0џ Ы
b
Ы
l јt0 TЁЁЁЁ Щ / ! " , / ! : ? @ > 5 : B C D 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = > 3 > 7 0 : > = 0 « 2 = 5 A 5 = 8 8 8 7 3 > : > 4 5 : A 0 > A A 8 9 A : > 9 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 F 8 8 8 $ 5 4 5 @ 0 ; L = K 9 7 0 : > = « 3 > A C 4 0 @ A B 2 5 = = > 9 @ 5 3 8 A B @ 0 F 8 8 ? @ 0 2 = 0 = 5 4 2 8 6 8 5 8 8 A 4 5 ; > : A = 8 = > ? @ > 5 : B 0 O 2 ; O 5 B A O A > 2 5 @ H 5 = A B 2 > 2 0 = 8 5 A 8 A B 5 1 A B 2 5 = = > A B 8 = 0 = 5 4 2 8 6 8 5 8 »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О Р €
| ~ Ђ ”OtPvPxP|P2R4RР_Т_мkоkрk`nbnщхрщищрщЮищрШрШрПШр CJ aJ mH sH CJ H* aJ 5 ЃCJ aJ mH sH 5 ЃCJ H* aJ CJ aJ 5 ЃaJ 5 ЃCJ aJ . t О Р Т ¤ €
Љ
Ђ V Ц D Ц $т&0*"1.8^
Прикрепленные файлы
Текст законопроекта
Пояснительная записка
Перечень актов федерального законодательства, подлежащих признанию утратившими силу, приостановлению, изменению, дополнению или принятию в связи с принятием Федеральный закона
Финансово-экономическое обоснование
24, п.73
30, п.61
Заключение Правового управления
31, п.88
Текст законопроекта
Заключение Комитета Государственной Думы по собственности
Заключение Комитета
37, п.92
Заключение Правового управления
Текст законопроекта
Таблица поправок, рекомендуемых комитетом к принятию
Заключение Правового управления
56, п.12
65, п.19
Заключение Правового управления
Текст законопроекта
Реакция фракций
Внутреннее кольцо показывает фракции, внешнее — распределение голосов внутри каждой фракции.
ЕДИНАЯ РОССИЯ
За · 94.4%
За 289 · Против 0 · Воздержались 0 · Не участвовали 17
КПРФ
Не участвовала · 97.9%
За 1 · Против 0 · Воздержались 0 · Не участвовали 46
СПРАВЕДЛИВАЯ РОССИЯ
За · 60.5%
За 23 · Против 0 · Воздержались 0 · Не участвовали 15
ЛДПР
Не участвовала · 100%
За 0 · Против 0 · Воздержались 0 · Не участвовали 27
Не входящие во фракции
За · 52.9%
За 9 · Против 0 · Воздержались 0 · Не участвовали 8
Фракция Народно-Патриотический Союз "Родина" (Партия Национального Возрождения "Народная Воля" - Социалистическая единая партия России - "Патриоты России")
За · 70%
За 7 · Против 0 · Воздержались 0 · Не участвовали 3
Поименные данные
Показано: 445